Thursday, April 25, 2013

( My Article Publsihed in Agweekly 2070-1-12 )

किन सफल भएन एपिपि ?
नेपालको कृषि क्षेत्रमा रहेका सम्पूर्ण नीतिहरूमा दीर्घकालीन कृषि नीति (एपिपि) लाई सर्बोत्क्रिस्ट मानिन्छ | अत्यन्त दुरदृस्टी मानिएको नीतिको हाल १८ वर्ष पछिको उपलब्धिको समीक्षा गर्ने हो भने सोचे भन्दा निकै कममात्र सफलता हासिल गरेको महसुस हुन्छ |आखिर दिर्घकालिन कृषि नीति किन सफल हुन सकेनत ? यस बिषयमा गम्भीर छलफल हुनु आवस्यकता हुन गएको छ | यो छलफल किन पनि महत्वपूर्ण छ भने, नेपाल सरकारले अबको करिब दुई वर्ष पछि अन्त हुने त्यसै नीतिको विकल्पमा कृषि बिकस रणनीति ( एडिएस ) समेत तयारी गरिरहेको छ |

दिर्घकालिन नीतिको आधारपत्रमा उल्लेख सामाजिक तथा राजनैतिक धरातल र नीति कार्यान्यन अवदीको  वास्तविकपरिवेशमा निकै अन्तर हुन गयो | दिर्घकालिन कृषि नीति निर्माण गर्दा देशको शान्ति सुरक्षाको बिसयमा केहि पनि सोच राखिएन | तर, नीति लागु हुदा नहुदै चर्किएको युद्धका कारण कतिपय ठाउमा राज्यको उपस्थिति नै भएन भने, कतिपय ठाउमा लगिएका कार्यक्रमहरु समेत सफलतापुवक संचालन हुन सकेनन | दिर्घकालिन नीति लाई दस बर्षे लामो युद्धले निकैनै असर पुगेको महसुस हुन्छ, परिणामस्वरुप, दिर्घकालिन नीतिको सफलतामा निकै नकारात्मक असर पुग्न गएको छ |

एपिपि आफैमा आकर्षक भए पनि राखिएका लक्ष्य बस्तुगत नभएको र आकर्षक बनाउने सोचमा वास्तबिकता भन्दा ज्यादै माथि कल्पना गरिएको महसुस हुन्छ | कृषि ऋण को रुपमा रु १०९.४ खर्ब रकम खर्च गर्ने भनि राखिएको लक्ष्यले यसकुराको पुस्टि गर्छ | कृषि बिकस बैंकको ऋण कृषि क्षेत्रमा बढाउदै लैजाने भनेर सोच राखिए पनि कृषि विकास बैंकले  क्रमसः कृषि ऋणको अनुपात घटाउदै लगेको छ |तसर्थ, सोचे अनुरुप लगानी नहुदा नीतिले परिकल्पना गरेका कतिपय महत्वकान्क्षि उपलब्धिहरू समेत प्राप्त हुन सकेनन |

लगानीको प्राथमिकता एक क्षेत्रमा गरिनु अनि त्यस्को प्रतिफल अर्को क्षेत्र बाट अपेक्षा राखिनु आफैमा बिरोधास्पूर्ण परिकल्पनाको रुपमा समेत दिर्घकालिन कृषि नीतिलाई लिन सकिन्छ| नीतिमा ब्यबस्था गरिए अनुरुपका मल , बिउ तथा सिचाई जस्ता क्षेत्र मा गरिने लगानीको प्रत्यक्ष असर  बाली उत्पादनमा देखिन्छ| तर उत्पादन को क्षेत्र मा राखिएका लक्ष्यमा प्रमुख खाद्यान्न वाली कहिँ पनि उल्लेख भएको पाहिन्न| यसै गरि पशुजन्य उत्पादन क्षेत्रहरुमा लक्ष्य निर्धारण गरिएपनि उल्लेखरुपमा कुनै पनि लगानी को ब्याख्या गरिएको पाहिन्न | फलस्वरुप कृषि गार्हस्थ उत्पादनमा पशुजन्य उत्पादन को हिस्सा ३१ प्रतिसत बाट ४५ प्रतिसतमा पुर्याउने लक्ष्य राखिएकोमा हाल आएर २५ प्रतिसतमा झर्न पुगेको छ |

दिर्घकालिन कृषि नीति असफल हुनुको प्रमुख कारण मध्ये एक कारण प्राथमिकताको क्षेत्रमा सरकार, व्यक्तिगत एवम दात्रि निकायहरूको लगानी नहुनु समेत रहेको छ |उदारहण स्वरूप,नीतिले कृषि व्यवसाय प्रबर्द्धन तर्फ स्याउ , सुन्तला जातका फलफूल, रेशम खेति एवम मौरी पालनमा बिशेस जोड दिएको पाहिन्छ| तर, यसै अवदीको  लगानीको मात्राहेर्ने हो भने यीनिहरू भन्दा भिन्न क्षेत्रहरुमाबढीलगानी भएको पाइयो| जसलेगर्दा अन्य क्षेत्र हरू जस्तै चिया, कफी तथा पुस्प व्यवसाय ज्यादा फस्टाएर गएको छ| यसरी, लक्ष्य र लगानीको तालमेलका कारण समेत कतिपय व्यवसाय अनुत्पादक रहेको प्रस्ट हुन जान्छ|

दिर्घकालिन कृषि नीतिको एक बाधक कारणहरू मध्ये नीतिगत दोहोरो बुझाई समेत रहेको छ l कृषि सडक र ग्रामिण सडक भिन्न कुरा हुन भन्ने नबुझ्दा धमाधम ग्रामिण सडक हरू निर्माण भए, तर कृषि सडकलाई बेवास्ता गरेको भान हुन्छ | बस्ती बस्तीमा बाटोहरु खोल्ने कार्य सुरु भए, तर कृषि उत्पादन पकेटहरुलाई बेवास्ता गरियो | एकातर्फ, सोचिएजस्तो सडक निर्माणकार्य हुन नसक्नु अर्को तर्फ कृषि सडक को परिकल्पनालाई तोडमोड गरेर बुझ्नु जस्ता कारणहरू समेत नीतिलाई असफल बनाउन भूमिका खेलेको पाहिन्छ|

जिम्मेवारीवहन तथा समन्वय र सहकार्यको समस्याको कारण समेत दीर्घकालीन कृषि नीतिको सफलतामा बाधा पुग्न गएको छ | नीतिको कार्यान्यन गर्ने निकायको रुपमा राष्ट्रिय योजना आयोगलाई तोकिए पनि यस कार्य कृषि बिकाश मन्त्रालयको मात्र दायित्व हो झैँ गरि, सम्बन्धित पक्षले लिदिनाले समेत समस्या थपिएको महसुस हुन्छ| वास्तवमा, यो सम्पूर्ण निकायको साझा लक्ष्य हो, यो नेपाल रास्ट्रको लक्ष्यहो र यो हामी सबैको लागि हो भन्ने धारणा बिकास हुन नसक्दा सोचेजस्तो सफलता हासिल हुन नसेकेको पाहिन्छ |

तसर्थ, कृषि बिकस रणनीति निर्माण र कार्यान्यन गर्दा दिर्घकालिन कृषि नीति बाट सिकेका सिकाई हरुसमेत ध्यान दिनु आवस्यकता हुन्छ| पहिले गरिएका गल्तिहरु नदोहोरिउन र नया परिबेसमा नया स्वरुपको नीति बिकास गरौ भन्ने अभिप्रायले कार्य गर्दा दिर्घकालिन नीतिका अनेकन उपलब्धि, चुनौती तथा अफट्याराहरू मार्ग दर्शक हुन गएका छन् |




Sunday, April 21, 2013


Wait for extreme hunger and eat till our belly is like a ball; is very common in Nepal. The information about importance of right food, at right time interval and at right quantity is still not disseminated well. As a result of which, even, educated circle of nation are not following the good routine.How much food a person should take per day ? It depends upon the many factor. First factor is your age; children and old age should have less whereas young should more. Second factor is Sex; it is scientifically verified that women should have less food than men. Similarly,  third factor would be the personal physical works; those having heavy physical exercises and works should obviously have more food than having light works. These are some of the major  factors; but there are many metabolic and external factors which an medical researcher can explain much better than an agriculturist like me. However, the principle of average should never be neglected. No such medical research  is found in Nepal. So, we are purportedly borrowing findings and recommendations from Indian Council of Medical Research for own use, considering the findings might be replicable to our situation.

Food requirement per person per day(ICMR 1985)
Food group
Requirement in gm*
Cereals
400-650
Pulses
55-80
Green vegetables
100-125
Roots and tubers
75-100
Other vegetables
75-100
Fruits
30
Milk
100-200
Meat or fish
30
Egg
30
Sugar
30-55
Fats and oil
35-50
Derived ICMR Recommendations (kg/person/year)
Food group    
lowest
highest
average
Cereals
146
219
183
Pulses
20
32
26
Green vegetables
37
46
41
Roots and tubers
27
37
32
Other vegetables
27
37
32
Fruits
11
11
11
Milk
37
73
55
Meat or fish
11
11
11
Egg
11
11
11
Sugar
11
20
16
Fats and oil
13
18
16
Total
350
514
432

Tuesday, March 26, 2013


Happy with my First Book. Hope people buy it and I  will get royalties collected in my bank account. Anyone interested in community forestry system in Nepal and Economic benefit taken by rural people ( mostly farmers) can have one copy of it. Some descriptive analysis, statistical tools and econometric models are used for socio-economic  analysis of community forestry.Anyway, Thank you LAP, Germany. 

Monday, March 25, 2013


New long term plan in agriculture sector of Nepal,  Agricultural Development Strategy (ADS ) is under formulation process. Before it comes to a full shape , it has tried to analyse the agriculture sector of Nepal in different perspectives. All together 12 thematic groups are formulated and working for policy documentation. How does this document keeps its full shape?; is matter of curiosity to all of us. In this background; some of the findings taken from ADS documents are as follows. These Indicators really worth to analyse agriculture sector performance in days to come.

Indicator
Value
Agricultural GDP
$5.2 billion
Productivity of Agricultural Labor
$700/person
Agricultural Land per Household
0.7 ha/hh
Productivity of Agricultural Land ($/ha)
$1,700/ha
Composition of AGDP
49% cereal, livestock 24%, fruit spice and vegetables 23%
Agricultural Land Use
Cereals 80% of total cultivated land
Seed turnover
8%
Employment in Agriculture
60%
Landless population
7% (less than 0.1ha); 47% of household with less than 0.5 ha
Agricultural Exports
$248 million
Agricultural Imports
$621 million
Poverty (2010 preliminary)
25%
Food Consumption Share
61% of expenditures
Animal protein consumption
Milk 51l/cap, Meat 9 kg/cap, Egg 23/cap, Fish 2 kg/cap
Stunting of Children (less than 5 years)
42%
Irrigation cover
54% of cultivated area
Infrastructure (road)
Rural Road Network = 40,000 km; Strategic Road Network = 20,000 km
ICT reach
46% of the population have access to telephone

Tuesday, March 19, 2013

Ministry of Agricultural Development has recently published " Statistical Information on Nepalese Agriculture, 2011/12 ( 2068/69)". Agribusiness Promotion and Statistical Division of Ministry publishes this book each year. Production figures of cereals, pulses, oil seeds  cash crops, fruits, vegetables, spices ,fish production, number and products of livestock and poultry  for year 2011/12 national, sub-national and district level are the main features of the book. Similarly, statistics of export and import of agricultural products, price statistics, credit statistics, irrigation statistics, food balance sheet, varieties of crops and cost of production statistics are also included. We are in the process of improving this, collecting suggestions from all.

http://www.moad.gov.np/download.php?id=62

Sunday, March 17, 2013


The comparison of poverty percentage from three living standard survey of Nepal shows poverty percentage  has decreased from 41.8 percent in 1994/95 to 25.16 in 2010/11. But the worrying situation here is about the urban poverty and poverty in far western region of Nepal. There was  only 9.6 percent of population below poverty line in urban area during second living standard survey which has gone up to reach 15.46 in third living standard survey. Migration of poor and  landless people toward urban area in search of better employment is believed to be the reason behind this. But if this trend continues, our urban areas would be full of poor very soon. Now increased poverty in far western region from 41 percent in second living standard survey to 45.61 in third NLSS  is matter of confusion. Many logic may be there to explain it. First, the living standard survey is a sample survey, was there sampling error?? Second, the level of income for poverty line has increased in third living standard survey. So the far western region might not have increased to catch up the overall national growth of income standard??


Saturday, March 16, 2013

Production Trend of Summer Cereals in Nepal (2000/01 to 2012/13) shows some good indication of agricultural development in Nepal. Use of hybrid seeds ( including HYV seeds) and increased rate of SRR is ultimately rewarding. On the top of that, initiatives from farmers level ( mechanization, proper fertilizer application and timely intercultural operations) is much encouraging.

Badri Khanal
Agriculture Economist
G.P.O. 23470, Kathmandu, Nepal
Email : badri.khanal1@gmail.com
The two third of Population in Nepal are still dependent on Agriculture profession for their Livelihood and one third of National Economy is still  dependent on Agriculture Sector. In terms of value, Agriculture GDP is increasing , but the rate of growth is far below than overall GDP growth of nation. This ultimately results percentage share of Agriculture Sector in National GDP is decreasing Year after year.
Does this indicate Improvement in Agriculture Production in Nepal ? yes, off course. But to the surprise of all, fruit's indicator is leader followed by vegetables. Before one and half decade, around 80 percent of our vegetables in market was from India and other countries. But our regular effort and people's awareness resulted self sufficiency in vegetable production. This index indicates our focus area should be shifted from cereals to horticultural crops.

Wednesday, March 13, 2013




                                                     My Article Published in Agriculture Weekly

Add caption

Wednesday, March 6, 2013

Not only Mountains but also terai and  hilly region of Nepal is facing problem related with nutrition. IT'S HORRIBLE, LETS DO SOMETHING


First of all, Nepal  divided into 15 sub ecological belts, each three ( mountain, hill and terai ) for  five development regions for the analysis. Then, 24 different indicators which are believed to have direct effect on food and nutrition security and which  we do have information for a longer period of time were chosen with consultation of all relevant stakeholders in food and nutrition security of Nepal. Based on IPC  ( Integrated Food Security Phase Classification ) based classification two ecological belts,  Eastern Terai and Western Terai were found to have in phase I while Far Western and Mid Western Mountain were found to have in Phase IV ( Worst Chronic Food Insecurity) and rest were in either Phase III or Phase II.

Thursday, February 21, 2013


The one and only Agricultural Institute of Tribhuban University, Institute of Agriculture and Animal Science (IAAS) is closed now since last one month .Government has no any interest to open it. A controversy created on handing over IAAS to new agriculture forestry university is the main reason for closing. 

Thursday, February 7, 2013

MY PUBLISHED ARTICLE IN INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SOCIAL FORESTRY ( IJSF)2011,4(2):139-152

Wednesday, February 6, 2013

 HIGHLIGHTS
• Anaemic agriculture investments threaten livelihoods
• Agriculture expertise stretched thin, or untapped
• One extension centre per 11,000 farmers
• Farmers giving up, migrating
KATHMANDU, 23 January 2013 (IRIN) - Agriculture in Nepal suffers from years of under-investment, limited research, and scant inputs, technology and services for farmers. Unless things change, Nepal may fall into deeper food insecurity and poverty, say analysts.

“Declining resource allocation to agriculture research and development will have direct implications on attaining the objective of poverty reduction, despite investment made on infrastructure,” noted a December 2012 paper by the US-headquartered International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI).

While most development plans give high priority to agriculture - which contributes 35 percent to GDP - government investment in the Ministry of Agricultural Development (MOAD) - has declined from 3.7 percent of all government spending 10 years ago to 2.6 percent this year. Meanwhile, overall government spending has doubled since 2006.

While MOAD saw a slight increase in government and donor funding following the 2008 global and national food crisis, its budget dropped this year by 27 percent to US$105 million compared to last year due to political squabbling that delayed agreement on an overall government budget. A partial no-growth budget to continue only ongoing programmes was agreed last November, four months late.

All this has meant a steeper slide into poverty for 66 percent of people nationwide who survive through agriculture.

The average farm size shrunk 36 percent from 1.1 hectares in 1995 to 0.7 hectares in 2010, often too small to generate income above the poverty line. “Despite overall reduction in poverty levels in the country, poverty for those self-employed in agriculture increased by 10 percentage points,” reported IFPRI.

“When investment is low, we cannot have new technology and programmes to generate employment and grow effectively,” explained Devendra Gauchan, agriculture economist and chief of the Socioeconomics and Agri-research Policy Division at the governmental Nepal Agricultural Research Council (NARC).

Extension services

Extension services are strained due to lack of staffing and funding. MOAD’s Department of Agriculture has 378 extension offices nationwide. Every agriculture outreach station serves more than 11,000 farmers; one technician is responsible for an average 1,500 farmers. In developed countries, the average is one per 400.

“We have not been able to provide farmers with the services they need,” said Yagya Raj Joshi, senior agriculture development officer at the Doti District Agriculture Development Office in the country’s Far West Region, known for its rough, mountainous terrain.

He heads a team of 30 staff, responsible for a population of 200,000 - 80 percent of whom are farmers, and 60 percent of whom still depend on increasingly erratic weather for their water.

“Our work is only small-scale,” he told IRIN, that there was no technology to transfer even if there were enough qualified experts to do it.

Most of MOAD’s budget goes on salaries and administrative costs; there is limited money for programming, said Prabhakar Pathak, joint-secretary and spokesperson at MOAD’s Gender Equity and Environment Division.

Compounding farmers’ woes, the current extension service model requires they go to district centres and sub-centres for assistance, leaving growers in remote areas most in need of support going without it, says IFPRI. “On average, rural households require more than two hours to reach their nearest markets or government service centres because of difficult terrain and a lack of transport infrastructure.”

Research

Minimal investment in research has hampered efforts to meet the challenges of increasingly volatile weather, said Gauchan, especially given Nepal’s agro-ecological diversity.

Less than 0.4 percent of the agriculture sector’s GDP is spent on research, far short of the internationally recommended 1 percent. NARC received US$11 million this year, 22 percent less than last year. Only 32 percent of the $11 million was for research. In tight times, money for equipment and maintenance of research labs and farms goes first, which has long-term repercussions, said Hari Krishna Shrestha, an agricultural economist at NARC.

Funding cuts disrupt the breeding, production and distribution of new, improved seeds to farmers, and prevents timely response to emerging pests.

Meanwhile, NARC’s staff numbers are declining. More than 40 percent of the scientists are nearing retirement age, while 32 percent of posts are vacant due to recruitment problems. It is especially difficult to find masters-level entomology, pathology, soil and other hard-science graduates, said NARC’s Gauchan.
Agriculture and animal sciences are niche studies, drawing in only 0.3 percent of higher education enrolment in 2009-10. “Young graduates are not attracted to public sector scientific organizations,” he added.

Loans hard to come by

Inputs needed to increase the land’s productivity - from seed, to fertilizer, machinery, irrigation, and finance - are scarce nationwide.

“Farmers hardly get compensation when their crops fail,” said Radha Nepal, a farmer and chairwoman of a maize seed production cooperative in Kashyauli village of south-central Palpa District. “And it is difficult for us to get loans, especially since most of our land is not held in the name of women, and our men have gone abroad.”

The government’s 2012 Agriculture Development Strategy Assessment Report estimated 200,000 youth, especially from rural areas, migrated abroad for employment in 2010, leaving mostly women, children and the elderly behind. Female-headed agricultural households have increased from 12 percent in 1995 to 26 percent in 2010. Yet only 18 percent of women in rural households own houses or land, according to the 2011 census.

In the last decade, the largely government-owned Agriculture Development Bank Limited has moved away from being a primary lender in agriculture, towards housing, vehicles, and commercial development.

In a 2010 analysis, Gauchan found the share of credit provided to agriculture was only 11 percent of the bank’s total lending portfolio due to the perceived high risk of investing in subsistence agriculture.

Some 54 percent of cultivated land in Nepal is irrigated, only 7 percent of households own a pump (not taking into account whether or not that pump actually works), and a mere 1 percent own tractors, power tillers, or threshers. The state-owned Agriculture Inputs Company Limited estimates fertilizer demand to be 500,000 tons, of which only 150,000 was supplied last year.

“On land where we could cultivate three harvests’ worth, we have to settle with only one,” said farmer Radha Nepal. “In the past, we had neither the technology nor the knowledge, now we have them, but we don’t have access to them.”

Bleak future?

MOAD spokesperson Pathak projected a bleak future unless things change: “The agricultural growth rate will decline. The contribution of agriculture to the GDP will decrease. There won’t be food and nutrition security. Agriculture job employment will decline. Youths will be less involved in agriculture, and the speed of income going abroad will increase.”

Some of those changes have already taken root. “Nobody wants to stay in agriculture,” said Sabnam Shivakoti Aryal, a senior agriculture officer at MOAD who is helping prepare a new long-term Agriculture Development Strategy (ADS), which will outline a 20-year vision and 10-year plan for Nepal.

“People are leaving land fallow where crops worth gold and silver can grow, to work as labourers making 10,000 to 12,000 rupees [$115-$139] a month,” said Joshi, the agriculture development officer in the Far West Region.

“If agriculture investment continues to be low, our poverty reduction efforts, and Millennium Development Goal (MDG) targets may not be possible,” added Gauchan. Nepal’s latest MDG progress report found that rural poverty - 28.5 percent - was four times higher than urban poverty - 7.6 percent. The overall MDG 2015 target for poverty is 21 percent.

Many in the government have set their hopes on the forthcoming ADS, with its promise of “sustainable growth in value in an agriculture sector that is more resilient to climate change”. A draft version is expected by March 2013.

Surya Prasad Paudel, a senior livestock development officer at MOAD who is also working on the ADS, listed a few of its preliminary proposals: increasing the share of the national budget that goes to agriculture; increasing the number of extension offices to nearly 900; and gradually committing up to 2 percent of agriculture-generated GDP to research. “If we invest in agriculture today, we will see the impact in 5-10 years’ time,” said Paudel.

The government approved in January 2013 four donor-funded agriculture projects worth $134 million (to which the state is contributing $32.5 million).

But Joshi is not optimistic. “I don’t trust them. So many strategies like the ADS have been developed,” he said, citing the last Agriculture Perspective Plan (APP) (1995-2015), which has seen many of its targets unmet. “I have been hearing that agriculture is the government’s priority since I was a child.”

Tuesday, January 8, 2013

"या देवी सर्व भुतेसू शक्ति रूपेण संस्थिता l
नामेस्तास्याई ll नामेस्तास्याई ll नामेस्तास्याई ll नमो नमः"
1.Human development index=HDI value =0.553, Rank in world=145

2.Human poverty index=HPI value=32.1, rank in world=99

3.Gender related development index=GDI as % HDI=98.4%, rank in world=112

4.Gender empowerment measure=GEM value=0.485, rank in world=83

Source: Human Development Report,2009, UNDP

  • Population engaged in agriculture = 65.5 %
  • GDP contribution by agriculture = 35.55 %
Every year government announces the budget speech and  Newspapers write in their front page as “Government announces the budget Speech Focusing on Agriculture Sector. “  Can the budget share of agriculture verify it?
  • Share of Agricultural Budget in National Budget ( in % age )
Year /Percentage
1997/98 =3.37
1998/99 =3.69
1999/00 =4.28
2000/01=3.93
2001/02=2.50
2002/03=2.75
2003/04=2.41
2004/05 = 2.65
2005/06 =2.45 
2006/07=2.47
2007/08=2.70
2008/09=2.76
2009/10=3.11
2010/11= 3.23

Saturday, December 15, 2012





My article in Annapurna Post National Daily, Nepal.

About The Blogger

About The Blogger
Badri Khanal is An Agriculture Economist from Nepal
Powered by Blogger.

Popular Posts

Total Pageviews

Flag Counter

Flag Counter

Disclaimer

This Blog does not represent communication for Blogger's Employer and Professional Societies. These are Blogger's personal views, experiences and whenever applicable cited from somewhere ( with citation given).

Feedback

Feedback to this blog can be delivered at badri.khanal1@gmail.com.